All episodes of Homicide: New York are now streaming on Netflix, with a Los Angeles installment premiering later this year.
By Greg Wheeler
Netflix’s new documentary series Homicide: New York stands out as one of the premier true crime offerings on the platform. Across its five episodes, the show delves deep into the terrain of murders primarily situated in Manhattan over the past three decades. What distinguishes Homicide: New York from similar fare is its dual perspective, narrating the narrative from both the law enforcement and victims’ standpoints.
The series illustrates how the New York Police Department (NYPD) became intimately involved in these cases on a personal level. Creator Dick Wolf employs a contemporary approach, blending archival footage, interviews, and reenactments to craft a compelling narrative that lingers with viewers.
Each of the five episodes explores a distinct case, ranging from serial rape to mass killings and property disputes. Some of these cases evoke profound emotions, while others may leave viewers unsettled. The series illuminates the complexities of these situations, showcasing the personal toll on families and the intricacies of investigations.
Viewers witness how a single murder can devastate multiple generations of a family or how seemingly ordinary teenagers can perpetrate acts more violent than adults. The show also delves into how the media can be a force for societal improvement while also uncovering instances of racism that victims may encounter from journalists.
Furthermore, Homicide offers insights into the judicial system, presenting examples of commendable judgment alongside moments that may challenge viewers’ faith in the legal process. The series also explores the challenges faced by law enforcement, revealing how even those with considerable authority can feel powerless in certain circumstances.
The first episode, titled “Carnegie Deli Massacre,” establishes the tone for the entire series. From the outset, the series distinguishes itself with its cinematography, soundtrack, and editing. The use of a green hue enhances the visual allure, capturing the audience’s attention. One scene in particular, depicts the killer ominously approaching their next victim after committing a murder in the same room. The meticulous staging of this scene, coupled with the background dialogue, leaves a lasting impact. As viewers immerse themselves in the series, they will come to appreciate its commitment to excellence in the technical aspects, exemplified by segments like this one.
In terms of storytelling, episodes three and four emerge as highlights, featuring intricate and eventful plots. The series offers commentary on various facets of society, including the judiciary, interdepartmental rivalry among Manhattan North and South detectives, the media’s influence on police cases, and more. A sentiment viewers will readily embrace while watching the show is that “reality is stranger than fiction.” The series depicts the setbacks faced by real-life heroes, demonstrating how even law enforcement officers grapple with personal turmoil. Viewers are confronted with the chilling reality of witnessing a loved one’s murder firsthand.
Moreover, the series captures instances of criticism from within the police department toward the judiciary, as well as emotional responses from officers when justice is finally served after protracted delays. These moments underscore that the series is not merely about recounting dry facts but compellingly presenting these homicide cases to the audience.
I give Homicide: New York a B+.
TV and City 