Overcompensating premieres May 15 on Prime Video.
By Elazar Abrahams
Overcompensating is a standout entry in the college comedy genre, delivering both hearty laughs and poignant moments. Created by and starring Benito Skinner, the series offers a semi-autobiographical look into the life of “Benny,” a closeted former high school football star navigating the complexities of college life and identity.
While the premise of a college freshman exploring sexuality and self-discovery isn’t novel, Overcompensating distinguishes itself through its sharp writing, authentic character dynamics, and a commitment to humor. The series doesn’t shy away from the raunchy aspects of college life and goes further than just flavored vodka, awkward hookups, and the quest for social acceptance. Impressively, it balances those ‘omg nsfw moments’ with genuine emotional depth.
Skinner’s lead performance is both hilarious and heartfelt. His chemistry with Wally Baram’s Carmen, a fellow freshman determined to reinvent herself, is a highlight. Their friendship anchors the series, providing both comedic and touching moments. Mary Beth Barone shines as Benny’s sister, Grace, offering sage advice and sibling banter, while Adam DiMarco’s portrayal of Peter, Grace’s over-the-top boyfriend, steals scenes with his exaggerated campus legend persona who becomes the season’s main antagonist.
The series also boasts an impressive roster of guest stars. Charli XCX makes a memorable appearance as herself, performing at a campus concert, while Bowen Yang and Matt Rogers deliver a hilarious joint cameo. Perhaps most notably, Connie Britton and Kyle MacLachlan portray Benny’s parents, bringing stellar comedic timing to their roles, especially in a standout Thanksgiving episode about halfway through the season that delves into family dynamics and personal growth.
Overcompensating has strong pacing, with each of the eight episodes feeling brisk yet substantial. The show’s humor is front and center, but even when Skinner’s writing ensures that while the situations are often exaggerated for comedic effect, the underlying emotions remain relatable.
In a landscape crowded with college comedies, Overcompensating manages to carve out its niche by being unapologetically bold, refreshingly honest, and consistently funny. It’s a testament to Skinner’s talent that the series feels both deeply personal and universally resonant. For those seeking a comedy that delivers both laughs and heart, this is one to check out.
I give Overcompensating an A-.
TV and City 