Dietland: Season 1 – Review

Dietland premieres June 4th, 9pm on AMC.

By Jeffery Shellenbarger

Dietland (based on the novel of the same name) centers around a woman called Plum Kettle—a ghostwriter for a fashion magazine who hopes to stop living in the shadows by slimming down through bariatric surgery. Being fat denies her many opportunities in both her career and love life, and after many failed attempts to lose weight via fad diets, she has taken to severe calorie restrictions in order to shed enough pounds to be eligible for surgery. What separates this story from so many other stories dealing with body image issues is the degree of realism presented in this show.

Joy Nash channels so much realism into Plum that you forget that Plum is a fictional character. In her side job as a baker at her gay best friend’s coffee shop, Plum bakes cakes that drive people wild. When she whips up a batch of frosting for a cake and takes a small taste, the look of terror she gives as she realizes that she ate outside of her allotted calories is one not-unfamiliar with anyone with body image issues. She rushes to the sink to not only wash out the frosting, but to wash out the shame.

This show goes beyond beauty standards, though. The show aims to build up women in general by also diving into the #MeToo movement. Lurking in the shadows of Plum’s story is a feminist revenge plot against men who make a habit of abusing women. Serial abusers are being kidnapped by women dressed as witches, being forced to confess for their crimes against women, and then being dropped to their deaths from highway overpasses, tall buildings, and aircraft. As we learn more and more about this scheme, we see how Plum may be connected.

As I watched my screener, Twitter was blowing up over Kim Kardashian’s endorsement of appetite suppressing lollipops. It seemed all too perfect as this is exactly the sort of thing addressed by the show—this whole industry that exists to make women feel inadequate. Kim Kardashian survives the patriarchy by playing her role in maintaining its system of oppression. Perhaps, like Plum, she will be given the opportunity to rise against it.

I give Dietland an A.

Julianna Margulies as Kitty Montgomery, Joy Nash as Plum Kettle – Dietland: Season 1, Episode 1 Photo Credit: Patrick Harbron/AMC

3 thoughts on “Dietland: Season 1 – Review

  1. OMG, finally, a man who gets it. Thank you for understanding. This show is so needed. We are in a time where half of the women are obese due to the poor quality of the food in the supermarkets and restaurants. Those of us who were thin when young, but became heavy with old age are very VERY aware of the prejudice that is out there against fat women. We have seen the prejudice from both sides of the issue. We remember the attention we got when we were thin and beautiful, as well as the sexual harassment that comes with that image. We now see the lothing, disgust, discrimination in the workplace, and the hear the snide comments made about us, now that we are fat. The prejudice against fat people is no different than racial prejudice. In fact, certain northern races are more prone to gain weight by virtue of their genetics. So fat hatred can be a form of racial prejudice: hatred toward people with genetics that make them more prone to store fat for times of famine. Dietland exposes and confronts this hatred. It also confronts the fact that women are still the last to receive equality, and the last to receive justice, in an unjust world. Half of the women in this country are obese. We feel the pain of discrimination. We need this show. Don’t let AMC cancel the show because AMC is run by male corporate “Heads”.

  2. “Dietland” has a lot reality. Plum’s struggle with her weight, body image and relationships is depicted in a very truthful way. But the surrounding over the top angry feminist fantasty detracts from this truth, and it’s not funny. Deitland is advertised a ‘dark comedy’ and though it’s very dark, I see no reason for laughter.
    Regrettably, the truth is overshadowed by anger. This is most unfortunate because, Plum’s message should be heard.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s