The Altruists – Review

The Altruists premieres November 19 on Netflix.

Continuing the trend of miniseries dramatizing startup disasters, comes Netflix’s The Altruists. In the last few year’s we’ve gotten WeCrashed for WeWork, Super Pumped tackling Uber, and The Dropout depicting Theranos. Now, it’s FTX and Sam Bankman-Fried’s turn.

For those unfamiliar, FTX was a cryptocurrency exchange run by Bankman-Fried, and Alameda Research, run by his friend and occasional lover Caroline Ellison, was the trading firm tied to it. The duo diverted ungodly sums of money between the companies, leaving an $8 billion hole in customers’ balances that couldn’t be withdrawn. A disaster definitely worthy of the television treatment, and a good one at that. Along with The Dropout, The Altruists is definitely on the better end of this genre of projects.

The show mostly keeps its focus on Sam and Caroline, and the strange mix of romance, friendship, and business between them is the crux of how it tells the story.

Anthony Boyle is legitimately excellent as Bankman-Fried. Devoted Netflix viewers may remember him from House of Guinness, where he played Arthur Guinness, a pompous, mustachioed Irishman that was heir to a brewing empire. Here, he is almost unrecognizable. Boyle completely disappears into the part, down to the awkward mannerisms and the way Sam seems to change shape depending on who is in the room. Watching him bounce off the other nerds, the media, and especially Caroline, tells you a lot about Sam’s insecurities without the show needing to stop and explain it. This is a transformative performance, and absolutely Emmy-nomination-worthy, if not an outright win.

Julia Garner is fun to watch, too, and she brings a big, almost hammy energy to Caroline. But where Boyle never quite tips into caricature, Garner sometimes does. Caroline can come across as simply the awkward, increasingly unhinged girl in the room. There is still something interesting in the performance, and I enjoyed it, but I found myself noticing the choices Boyle was making with more admiration. His feels like a more nuanced, more carefully calibrated piece of work.

The show is paced really well, and the flashback/flash-forward structure helps. At the beginning of the eight episodes, you know there’s going to be a scandal and jail time. I mean, obviously, if you’re watching the show, you probably already know that. But bouncing between Sam and Caroline’s first meeting and their fallout after they become billionaires is a clever way to keep the tension up. Just as their relationship is taking shape, we get a reminder of what they’re headed toward and how much damage they did.

My bigger reservation is that the series keeps its camera very close to Sam and Caroline. That makes for an intimate, sometimes surprisingly sympathetic portrait of two people who hurt a lot of people. The show does not absolve Sam, but it gives real weight to the idea that he wanted to do good through effective altruism, then kept digging himself deeper as everything went wrong.

But the world around FTX is mostly missing. One of the most fascinating things about The Dropout was the space it left for the question of how Elizabeth Holmes persuaded so many powerful people to believe in Theranos without ever needing to show them convincing evidence that its product worked. The Altruists could have used more of that outside perspective. Millions of ordinary people put money into FTX. Tom Brady endorsed it. Larry David appeared in a Super Bowl ad. FTX even paid to put its name on the Miami Heat’s arena. That level of hype is hard to overstate, and just a few of these details alone could have been a whole story about how enormous and credible this company seemed at the time.

Instead, those details get a mention while the series stays with Sam, Caroline, their parents, coworkers, and friends. We do not spend much time with the people around the world whose accounts were locked, or with a culture that treated crypto as the future. I wanted more of that scale and fallout. It might also have made the story feel less sympathetic, because the show sometimes makes the collapse feel like two people getting pulled down a rabbit hole rather than a cultural phenomenon that millions of people around the world bought into. I kept waiting for the show to open up and spend time in that world. Still, two great lead performances and exciting business intrigue make this definitely worth a watch.

I give The Altruists an A-.